Ionic liquids (ILs) are
liquid salts consisting entirely of ions with asymmetric, elastic, and
charge-localized structures. As their name implies, they remain liquid over a wide
range of temperatures having the melting temperature near room temperature or
by convention below 100oC[1–8]. After alcohol
and organic solvents, ILs are now regarded as the third class of solvents. ILs
are generally categorized into: protic and aprotic [9].In protic ionic
liquids (PILs), generally formation of the cation takes place by a simple
transfer of a proton from a Brønsted acid to a Brønsted base and PILs thus
formed consist of anion and cation held together by ionic interactions[9–16].Because of
their excellent proton conductivity, thermal stability, non-flammability, large
electrochemical windows and low vapor pressure, PILs have recently attracted a
lot of interest as potential candidates for alternate fuel cell electrolyte
applications[17–23].
Thermo physical
properties must be well-understood in order to develop any PILs-related
industrial processes[10,
24–26].
In addition, such results are vital to assess thermodynamic
Scheme-1. Synthesis of
[demaH] CF3COO- and its
binary mixtures with alcohols.
|
models and serve as a
valuable source of basic information regarding molecular interactions[27,28].The preparation
and development of PILs with tunable structures and physicochemical properties
are indeed a significant challenge and an area of active research. The ability
to fine-tune these properties is crucial for tailoring PILs to specific
industrial applications.
ILs are indeed known
for their relatively high viscosities compared to traditional solvents, which
limit their commercial use to some extent. However, research and development in
the field of ILs have been ongoing, and certain progresses have been made. To
overcome this limitation, one important strategy involves mixing ILs with other
solvents or additives to lead to the formation of IL-based binary mixtures with
lower viscosity and enhanced conductivity for lowering the energy requirements
for any engineering process [29–31].Thus, synthesis
of novel PILs and optimization of the factors governing their unique features
have attracted much attention. However, generally PILs are highly expensive and
PILs based binary solvents are considered to have the potential to offer a
unique way for modifying the properties of these designer solvents. To date,
there are very few attempts to investigate physicochemical properties of
PILs-based binary mixtures, although there are enormous studies in the case of
typical aprotic ionic liquids (AILs).The properties of ILs depend on several
factors; alkyl chain length has so far been the most crucial one to tune the
properties[32–34].With the
incredible expansion of PILs, enormous interest has been focused on the
determination and understanding of the physicochemical properties, which may be
significantly affected by molecular solvents such as alcohols either
deliberately added or absorbed. Therefore, the knowledge of interactions
between PILs and alcohols with various alkyl chain lengths is very important
for the use of PILs for various applications.
In this study,
neutralized a tertiary amine, diethylmethylamine (dema) with trifluoroacetic
acid (CF3COOH) to prepare a PIL, [demaH]CF3COO-.
[demaH]CF3COO-was mixed with ethanol, 1- propanol,
1-butanol, and 1-pentanolat a broad range of compositions to have a series of
binary mixtures. The transport properties such as density, viscosity, and ionic
conductivity of the PIL and its binary mixtures were measured at 30oC
to realize the effect of alkyl chain length of alcohols on the physicochemical
properties of [demaH]CF3COO- at a fixed temperature.
2. Materials & methods
Diethylmethylamine
(dema) (>97.0%) from Sigma-Aldrich, trifluoroacetic acid (99.5%) from
Scharlau, Spain, and ethanol, 1-propanol, 1-butanol, and 1-pentanol from RCI
Lab scan were used without further purification.
2.1 Preparation of PIL and its binary
mixtures
[demaH]CF3COO-
was synthesized according to Scheme 1by
mixing trifluoroacetic acid with the dema in equimolar amounts in a vial
placedin an ice bath. The mixture was sonicated for 60 min and the resulting
PIL was stored inside in an electrical desiccator. The DpKa of the constituents, dema (10.5) and CF3COOH
(0.5) of [demaH]CF3COO- is 10.0 [5,7].
All the mixtures of
[demaH] CF3COO- and alcohols were prepared in volume
percentage by using a micropipette. Each of binary mixtures was sonicated for
60 min.
2.2 Characterizations
The density was
measured using a small amount of PIL and its binary mixtures with alcohols
(less than 2 mL), introduced into a U-shaped borosilicate glass tube and
thermostated at 30oC in each case. After each measurement, the
U-shaped tube was cleaned with ethanol and ultrapure water. Ultrapure water was
prepared by BOECO pure (Model:BOE-8082060, Germany).
1 mL of sample was
injected into a glass capillary and placed into a capillary block at 30oC
to measure the viscosity. This block was angled in a variety of predetermined
directions. Based on the approximate viscosity of the combination, the
measuring angle, capillary diameter for sampling, and ball diameter were
chosen. The viscosities of all binary mixtures were determined using a Lovis
2000 M/ME microviscometer with an accuracy of 10-6 mPa.
The Autolab PGSTAT302N,
a high-performance impedance analyzer with FRA32M module, was used to assess
conductivity using electrochemical impedance spectroscopic (EIS) tests over a
frequency range of 10 Hz to 10MHz.A glass electrode was used to measure
solution resistance. The glass electrode was made up of two small Pt wires. One
of which worked as the working and other as the counter electrode.0.01M aqueous
solution of KCl was used to determine the cell constant at 30°C.
3. Results and discussion
3.1 Density
Fig. 1.depictsthe density of
[demaH]CF3COO-and its binary mixtures at 30oC.The
nature of the alcohol has been found to influence density of PIL very strongly.
The density of binary mixtures with alcohol increases non-linearly with the
increasing mole fraction of [demaH]CF3COO-.
Fig.1. Density vs. mole fraction of [dema]CF3COO-
for different alcohols in the binary mixtures at 30 oC.
3.2 Viscosity
The variation of dynamic
viscosity of the prepared binary mixtures with the mole fraction of [demaH]CF3COO-
is shown in Fig. 2.
Fig.2. Viscosity vs. mole fraction of [dema]CF3COO-
for different alcohols in the binary mixtures at 30 oC.
The viscosities decreased with
the increasing mole fraction of the alcohols at 30oC. Addition of
alcohols to PIL results in a weakened interactions between the ionic species
and the hydrogen bonding might also be weakened [35]. Therefore, viscosity
decreases with increasing mole fraction of alcohols.
3.3 Conductivity
The conductivity values of PIL
and its binary mixtures with alcohols at 30oC are shown in Fig. 3.
The conductivity of [demaH]CF3COO- was 5.25 mScm-1 at
30oC. Conductivity of PIL increases upon the addition of alcohols at
all compositions. However, the maximum
value of the conductivity of [demaH]CF3COO--ethanol
([demaH]CF3COO--alcohol = 0.25:0.75) is the highest (15.76
mScm-1 at 30oC)
compared to other [demaH]CF3COO--alcohol ratio.
Fig.3. Conductivity vs. mole fraction of
[dema]CF3COO- for different alcohols in the binary
mixtures at 30 oC.
Generally,
the conductivity of the binary mixtures decreases as the alkyl chain length of
the added alcohol is increased. The profiles for conductivity of [demaH]CF3COO-
and its binary mixtures with alcohols are shown in Fig. 3. Similar trends were
observed for molar conductivity at 30oC. In case of the PIL, the
number of charge carriers might be increased upon dissolution in a polar
solvent like alcohol, but PILs can also enhance the viscosity of the ternary
mixtures [26]. The consequences of more charge
carriers and less ion mobility are apparent in the ionic conductivity vs.
concentration of PIL profiles. In the low concentration range, the number of
charge carriers (ionic species that can conduct electricity) provided by the
PIL becomes the primary factor influencing the overall ionic conductivity.
Other factors dominate the ion mobility with changes in the PIL mole fraction
in the binary mixtures ; as a result, the ionic conductivity achieves its
maximum value before gradually decreasing [36].Addition of different
concentrations of alcohol lowers both the charge density and viscosity of a
pure PIL. Depending on the concentration of alcohol, its dilution effect
becomes more noticeable which can increase or decrease the conductivity of a
PIL. Addition of alcohol to PIL can enhance the movement of this charge
carriers which in turn increase the electric conductivity of the solution. In
case of high PIL concentration, attractive interactions among ions results in
the aggregation of charge carriers. Consequently, the mobility of the charge
species is lowered for a rise in viscosity. Therefore, electric conductivity of
the solution tends to drop in the high concentration of PIL [26,37–43].
3.4 Excess molar volume
Realizing the nature of
molecular association in binary mixtures depends greatly on excess
thermodynamic parameters, which are dependent on composition and temperature.
The excess molar volume, VmE is the deviation from
the ideal behavior. The VmE for all mixtures was
derived using the density of corresponding mixtures. Fig. 4 shows change of VmE
of [demaH]CF3COO-–alcohol binary mixtures over the
whole composition at 30oC along with the profiles fitted to
Redlich-Kister equation:
)i
where, Ai is
the fitting coefficient and x2 is the mole fraction of
[demaH]CF3COO-.
The VmE of binary mixtures of [demaH]CF3COO-and alcohols were positive for the mole
fraction range 0.6 to 1.0, on the other hand, [demaH]CF3COO-and its binary mixtures with alcohols shows
negative deviation at the mole fraction range 0.0 to 0.6. At 30oC,
the VmE of [demaH]CF3COO- –
alcohols and its binary mixtures changed with the alkyl chain length of the
alcohol. The positive value indicates that expansion of volume occurs when two
components are mixed. Positive values of VmE are
explained by the breakdown of chemical and non-chemical interactions between
the molecules.
Fig.4. Excess molar volume, VmE for
[demaH]CF3COO--alcohol mixtures as a function of mole
fraction of [demaH]CF3COO- at 30oC.
The negative value reveals a
more effective packing or attractive interaction when [demaH]CF3COO-
and alcohol come closer in the binary mixtures. In the pure systems, the ions
of [demaH]CF3COO- interact through hydrogen bonding
though the alcohol have weak dipole-dipole interactions. Mixing of alcohol with
PIL makes a mutual dissociation of dipole-dipole interaction in alcohol and
breaking or weakening of hydrogen bonds in PIL encompassing ions and consequent
formation of new hydrogen bonds leading to a contraction in volume, thus
resulting into negative VmE [44,45].
It can be assumed that there
is a breakdown of the mode of association in pure bulk PIL and pure alcohol by
hydrogen bond formation between two components in the mixture. This is weaker
than the electrostatic interactions between
the cations and anions in pure PIL to cause positive deviation of volume from
the ideal behavior [46–48].
3.5 Excess Viscosity
Fig. 5. shows sigmoidal
curves for deviation of viscosity vs mole fraction of [demaH]CF3COO-
profiles over the total composition range of [demaH]CF3COO-–alcohols
mixtures. The deviation at all compositions has been found to be negative at 30oC.
Fig. 5. Excess viscosity as function of mole fraction of [demaH]CF3COO-
at 30oC.
Although temperature has a
significant impact on viscosity deviation, changes in temperature have little
influence on the composition at which the smallest deviation is noted. The
excess viscosity of [demaH]CF3COO- and their binary
mixtures with alcohol at 30oC is shown in Fig. 5. The ideal
viscosity of liquid mixtures can be represented by Bingham’s equation which is
based on the principle of additivity.
Ƞ = XIL ƞIL + Xa ƞa
Where, Ƞ is the
viscosity deviation, XIL and Xa are the mole fraction of
pure PIL and alcohols, IL and a are the
viscosity of PIL and alcohols. The deviation of observed viscosity from the
ideal behavior is the excess viscosity of the binary mixtures. The change of
excess viscosity provides a qualitative assessment of the strength of probable
intermolecular interactions. Generally, the excess viscosity of all seven
binary mixtures of [demaH]CF3COO- with alcohols was found
to be negative. The viscosity attained a more negative value as the mole fraction
of [demaH]CF3COO- in the binary mixtures increased [49]. Negative value inferred that
the experimental viscosity is lower than the calculated ideal viscosity. In
general, negative excess viscosity is observed due to the inclusion of alcohol
molecules in the matrices of larger species. When alcohol is mixed with pure
PIL, the hydrogen bonds between [demaH]+ and CF3COO-
in the quasi-three-dimensional network of PIL might be weakened with the
formation of a hydrogen bond between the cation and alcohol molecules [50].Therefore, mobility of the
cation and anion become higher and the resistance to flow decreases which
results in the lower viscosity of solution compared to the ideal value. The
excess viscosity was more negative with increasing alkyl chain of the alcohols.
For a further understanding, the density, viscosity, conductivity, VmE
and Dh of binary mixtures are compared in Table 1.
Table 1. Density r,
viscosity h,
conductivity s, excess
molar volume VmE
and viscosity deviations Dh for
various binary mixtures at 30oC.
[demaH]CF3COO- +
Ethanol
[demaH]CF3COO-
|
r/g.cm-3
|
h/mPa.s
|
s/mS.cm-1
|
VmE/m3mol-1
|
Dh/mPa.s
|
0.25
|
1.0390
|
6.2230
|
15.6700
|
-0.5250
|
1.8457
|
0.35
|
1.0597
|
6.9330
|
14.5390
|
-0.7418
|
1.1894
|
0.50
|
1.0866
|
7.2270
|
12.0360
|
-1.1086
|
-0.5662
|
0.65
|
1.1117
|
8.3460
|
9.4931
|
0.3904
|
-1.4967
|
0.75
|
1.1475
|
10.1800
|
8.3178
|
0.7220
|
-1.0291
|
0.85
|
1.1521
|
11.3800
|
7.6335
|
0.9689
|
-1.1955
|
1.00
|
1.1819
|
14.6250
|
5.2100
|
|
|
[demaH]CF3COO- + 1-
Propanol
[demaH]CF3COO-
|
r/g.cm-3
|
h/mPa.s
|
s/mS.cm-1
|
VmE/m3mol-1
|
Dh/mPa.s
|
0.25
|
0.9600
|
5.1700
|
9.6200
|
-0.7191
|
0.2193
|
0.35
|
1.0099
|
6.2480
|
9.9800
|
-0.8148
|
7.3500e-3
|
0.50
|
1.0668
|
7.0410
|
10.2420
|
-1.3745
|
-1.1345
|
0.65
|
1.1061
|
7.8140
|
8.7300
|
0.4917
|
-2.2964
|
0.75
|
1.1333
|
9.7320
|
8.3800
|
0.9302
|
-1.6683
|
0.85
|
1.1417
|
10.8200
|
7.5930
|
1.2730
|
-1.8702
|
1.00
|
1.1819
|
14.6250
|
5.2100
|
|
|
[demaH]CF3COO- + 1-
Butanol
[demaH]CF3COO-
|
r/g.cm-3
|
h/mPa.s
|
s/mS.cm-1
|
VmE/m3mol-1
|
Dh/mPa.s
|
0.25
|
0.9546
|
4.5060
|
9.2150
|
-0.9086
|
-0.7854
|
0.35
|
1.0004
|
5.8070
|
8.6900
|
-1.0065
|
-0.7289
|
0.50
|
1.0541
|
6.9260
|
8.2400
|
-1.5418
|
-1.4766
|
0.65
|
1.0978
|
7.5530
|
8.0860
|
0.6460
|
-2.7163
|
0.75
|
1.1143
|
9.2890
|
7.9800
|
1.0265
|
-2.2248
|
0.85
|
1.1408
|
10.6300
|
7.5700
|
1.5512
|
-2.1283
|
1.00
|
1.1819
|
14.6250
|
5.2100
|
|
|
[demaH]CF3COO- + 1-
Pentanol
[demaH]CF3COO-
|
r/g.cm-3
|
h/mPa.s
|
s/mS.cm-1
|
VmE/m3mol-1
|
Dh/mPa.s
|
0.25
|
0.9414
|
3.3980
|
5.2360
|
-0.9612
|
-2.5278
|
0.35
|
0.9838
|
5.3860
|
6.8340
|
-1.1165
|
-1.6997
|
0.50
|
1.0491
|
6.8200
|
7.9300
|
-1.7599
|
-2.0055
|
0.65
|
1.0803
|
7.5290
|
7.9200
|
0.7829
|
-3.0364
|
0.75
|
1.1121
|
9.2770
|
7.8400
|
1.2649
|
-2.4483
|
0.85
|
1.1330
|
10.1700
|
7.4560
|
1.6730
|
-2.7152
|
1.00
|
1.1819
|
14.6250
|
5.2100
|
|
|
3.6 Effect of alkyl chain length on the density
The rof [demaH]CF3COO- and its
binary mixtures with alcohols for change in the carbon number of the alcohol is
shown in Fig. 6.
Fig. 6. Density
of [demaH]CF3COO- binary mixtures as a function of carbon
number of the alcohol.
The r of [demaH]CF3COO- and its
binary mixtures with alcohol decrease with an alkyl chain of the alcohols as
well as the mole fraction of PIL. Therefore, alkyl chain length of the alcohol
affects the r of the PIL
strongly. PIL- alcohol binary mixtures are highly dense compared to the pure
alcohols at 30oC. When the mole fraction of the alcohol increases,
aggregation between [demaH]CF3COO- – alcohol decreases
and the volume of the binary mixtures increases so that the r of the binary mixtures decreases with
the alkyl chain length of the alcohol. However, the r of pure alcohol increases with the
alkyl chain length.
3.7
Viscosity of PIL and its Binary mixtures
The h of [demaH]CF3COO- and its
binary mixtures with alcohols as a function of carbon number are shown in Fig.
7. The change in the h with the change of the alkyl chain of the
alcohol was observed in this case. At high composition ratios, such as (PIL:
Alcohol = 0.35:0.65; 0.25:0.75), the effect of the alkyl chain is very large.
Generally, viscosity decreases with increasing chain length of the alkyl group
of the alcohols. However, the hof pure alcohol increases with the alkyl
chain length.
Fig.7. Viscosity
of [demaH]CF3COO- binary mixtures as a function of carbon
number of the alcohols.
Usually, the high electrostatic
interactions between the cation and anion of PIL give the distinct
physicochemical properties of PIL. Furthermore, van der Waals forces and
hydrogen bonds, also play an important role for the characteristic properties
of PIL and alcohol binary mixtures.
3.8
Conductivity of PIL and its binary mixtures
The conductivity of [demaH]CF3COO-
and its binary mixtures with alcohols as a function of carbon number is shown
in Fig. 8.
Fig.8.
Conductivity of [demaH]CF3COO- binary mixtures as a
function of carbon number of the alcohols.
The conductivity decreases with
increasing the alkyl chain length of the alcohols and increases with increasing
the mole fraction of the alcohols. This is attributed both to the decrease in
mobility due to the increase in mass and to the higher tendency to form
clusters via hydrophobic interaction between the hydrocarbon chain of the
alcohols.
3.9 Walden Plot
The
ionicity of
[demaH]CF3COO- and its binary mixtures with alcohols was investigated using Walden Plot. A plot of logL vs. log(1/h) following the Walden rule was constructed using data for a 0.01
M aqueous KCl solution used as the reference. Hence, an “ideal” line
corresponds to the ionic chracteristics of an ideal electrolyte with a slope of
unity [51–53].
Fig.
9. Walden plot of PIL-alcohol binary mixtures at 30oCwith reference
to 0.01 M KCl.
The vertical distance from this ideal
line at log(1/h) is used to
categorize PILs as super-ionic,
good, poor, or non-ionic[54,55]. Fig. 9 shows the Walden plot
for binary mixtures and pure PIL investigating the ionic nature of these binary
mixtures in comparison with the PIL. Walden plots for binary mixtures of [demaH]CF3COO-– alcohols resided below the ideal line for 0.01M KCl solution. From the Walden
plot, it was revealed that PIL and its binary mixtures are poor PILs.
4. Conclusion
Physicochemical
properties of a PIL, [demaH]CF3COO- and its binary
mixtures with alcohols of varying alkyl chain lengths have been investigated. A
decrease in the density, viscosity, and conductivity with increasing alkyl
chain length of the alcohol is observed. The experimental data for the density
and viscosity of the binary mixtures of PIL with ethanol, 1- propanol,
1-butanol, and 1-pentanol at 30 oC were fitted to evaluate excess
molar volumes, VEm, and viscosity deviations, Dη, of these binary
mixtures. The VEm was found negative at low PIL
concentrations (PIL< 0.50) and positive at high PIL concentrations (PIL >
0.50). The stronger association of the PIL-alcohol was probably responsible for
this negative effect. The excess viscosity of all binary mixtures of [dema]CF3COO- -alcohol was found
negative for almost all cases. From the Walden plot, it was revealed
that PIL and its binary mixtures are poor PILs.